
| Mediation
or Litigation? |
| Mediation |
Litigation |
| Parties
make own decisions |
Attorneys
make decisions |
| Parties
85-90% more likely to abide by decisions they make
|
Parties
less likely to abide by decisions attorneys make |
| Costs
much less |
Costs
can be exorbitant |
| Takes
much less time |
Can
go on for years |
| Communication
is civil, respectful |
Attorneys
encourage sides only to “speak” through
them |
| Personal/professional
issues stay private |
Issues
open to public record |
 |
| Some mediators from left: Loyal Smith,
Laurette Cocklin, Sharon Loucka, John Bertschler,
Michelle Russell, Thomas O'Reilly, Barbara Neilsen
|
|
What is mediation?
Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party (the
mediator) facilitates the resolution of conflict involving
two parties.
Sometimes, parties are already in agreement as to
how they would like their resolution to be.
For example:
- A married couple agrees to a marital dissolution. They
have a fairly solid understanding of how to divide their
assets, their time spent with children, and material goods
in the house.
- A business which wants to buy out another business wants
to make certain that this is a fair agreement for all parties
involved. No one is arguing; they just want to have a mediator
verify they have not omitted anything crucial in the agreement.
At other times, parties are in heated dispute.
For example:
- A husband and wife who have each retained an attorney
over a year ago, but are getting nowhere in filing for divorce.
- A couple who wants a mediator but cannot agree on how
to divide their portfolio.
- A church whose pastor has a different understanding of
how to run the church from the elder council.
- A school board in heated debate with teachers regarding
salary increases.
In either case, parties who are willing to dialogue about
the issues are good candidates for mediation.
What are the steps
in mediation?
Preliminary steps include a free consult
to determine is there is a good “fit” between
the needs of the client and the services we provide. We spend
time making sure the parties have a good understanding of
the mediation process before we begin the formal steps.
Step 1. Introductions and Ground Rules
Step 2. Both parties involved present their
side of the story
Step 3. Issues are clarified, summarized,
and prioritized. Both parties need to understand each other’s
needs.
Step 4. Creative brainstorming of possible
solutions.
Step 5. Narrowing range of options to
best and most workable solution(s).
Step 6. Documentation of agreement and
signing of agreement by both parties.
At times, a subsequent meeting is set up to determine how
well the agreement is working. Because parties now know the
process, they can also meet without the mediator as long as
they follow these basic steps. If at any point one or the
other party refuses to continue the mediation, each party
maintains the right to investigate the option of litigation.
| Frequently asked questions about
Mediation |
1. How does
mediation differ from arbitration?
Arbitration is a process whereby two parties present
their cases to the arbitrator who decides which
has the best or strongest argument. The parties
must abide by the decision of the arbitrator. One
side wins; the other loses. |
2. How much does mediation
cost?
Costs vary from practice to practice and depending
on several variables, e.g., use of more than one
mediator, length of time, etc.
In general in our practice, Divorce Mediation costs
$120 per hour payable at the time of service. Document
preparation is $60 per hour.
Family mediation costs $120 per hour and is payable
at the time of service.
Business mediation costs $150 per hour. Costs go
up if a second mediator or expert in a field is
used, e.g., a contractor or engineer in a construction
dispute. In general, fees are payable at the time
of service. |
3. Is mediation covered
by insurance?
No. Just like legal fees, mediation is an out-of-pocket
expense. |
4. If we mediate our divorce,
do I still need an attorney?
In divorce mediation, a couple has the legal right
to file pro se. However, because most people
are unfamiliar with the court system, we always
recommend you hire one attorney to a) review our
mediated document and b) help you file at the court
house. Attorney fees are separate. |
5. What if I don’t
have an attorney?
NCS frequently makes referrals to “mediator-friendly”
attorneys who understand and support the mediation
process, don’t charge a retainer to our clients,
and only charge for the several hours it may take
to review and re-format the Document of Understanding,
and help file for marriage dissolution at the courthouse. |
6. Why can’t my mediator
represent my case in court?
This is strictly forbidden, because it is illegal
for a mediator or anyone else to “practice
law” without a law degree. |
7. How long does mediation
take?
In divorce mediation, the average range is between
8 and 14 hours.
In business, church, school, construction mediation,
a case may take 1/2 day, 1 day, or several days
depending on the complexity of the case.
In all mediations, variables include how open people
are to being respectful, if more information needs
to be gathered once the process begins, and the
time constraints of parties involved to name some. |
8. How can I tell if I
have a good mediator?
Several ways. A mediator does not take sides. He/she
does not “represent” either party, but
stays neutral, helping parties communicate respectfully
with no name calling or dredging up the past. The
mediator is alert to suggestions one party might
make which does not seem equitable or fair to the
other party. A new client is wise to ask the mediator
how long he/she has been in practice, how many cases
worked, and what type of training the mediator received. |
9. Are mediators bound
by professional standards of conduct?
Absolutely. Though an unregulated field, reputable
mediators belong to the Association for Conflict
Resolution (ACR) or local/regional groups. Northcoast
Conflict Solutions belongs to ACR and is active
in the Mediation Association of Northeast Ohio (MANO). |
10. What can be mediated?
Issues that can be resolved in mediation are wide-ranging.
They involve:
• Divorce matters
such as child support, residential visitation, health
insurance, spousal support, college expenses of
children, debts, tax matters, allocation of marital
assets including then home, furnishings, etc. portfolio
holdings and more.
• Post-mediation matters including any changes
in family situations which need to be re-decided,
e.g., parental time with children no longer works
now that they have become teenagers, etc.
• Family mediation
may involve blended family conflicts, holiday decisions,
caregiver issues
• Elder mediation
including issues such as living arrangements, driving,
estate matters, disputes involving Living Will or
other medical care.
• Medical or Nursing Home Mediation involving
disputes with hospitals or residential care centers
regarding negligence, quality of care, or other
serious conflict between a family and a hospital
or retirement center.
• Church or School
Mediation
• Construction
Mediation
• Debt/credit Mediation |
|
|